The issue of justification of application of the principle of self-determination of peoples by separatist formations in Ukraine
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31548/law2021.04.018Abstract
The article provides an analysis of the possibility of separatist formations in Ukraine to refer to the principle of self-determination of peoples as a justification for their activities. The minimum necessary criteria of legal bases for self-determination are considered, among which: the existence of effective connection of the subject of self-determination with a certain territory; the existence of the subject itself, i.e., the people (ethnic group), which claims self-determination; and the recognition by the international community of such a potential entity as the bearer of the right to self-determination.
Regarding the connection with the territory, the doctrine of international law and practice recognizes the right to cultural and national self-determination in a particular territory for any ethnic group. This right is limited to the common interests of all the people of the state, which consists in the unconditional preservation of the inviolability and integrity of its territory.
As for the existence of the subject of self-determination, the people is recognized as the historical community of people formed in a certain area and have stable features of the language, culture, and mental composition (mentality), as well as aware of their unity and difference from others through conscious self-name. At the same time, diasporas and migrants must be subject to the laws of the country of residence under the right of citizenship or the right of permanent residence.
As for the recognition of the subject of self-determination by the international community, it may recognize as the people those who are under colonial rule, occupation by a foreign state, or against whom a policy of racism is pursued. Thus, international law does not protect separatist movements aimed at secession if they do not meet these criteria.
This means that separatist formations in Ukraine do not have the right to secession but are terrorist organizations in terms of their methods of activity.
Keywords: people, international recognition, right to self-determination, secession, territory
References
Ostroukhov, N.V. (2010). Territorialnaya tselostnost gosudarstv v sovremennom mezhdunarodnom prave i yeye obespecheniye v Rossiyskoy Federatsii i na postsovetskom prostranstve [Territorial integrity of states in modern international law and its provision in the Russian Federation and in the post-Soviet space]. Moscow, 62. Available at: https://www.dissercat.com/content/territorialnaya-tselostnost-gosudarstv-v-sovremennom-mezhdunarodnom-prave-i-ee-obespechenie-/read/pdf (in Russian).
Antselevich, G.A. (2012). Nekotoryye aspekty razvitiya nauki i praktiki mezhdunarodnogo morskogo prava v suverennoy Ukraine [Some aspects of the development of science and practice of international maritime law in sovereign Ukraine]. International law as the basis of the modern world order: the collective monography Liber Amicorum for the 75th anniversary of prof. V.N. Denisov, 505–519 (in Russian).
Baburin, S.N. (1998). Territoriya gosudarstva: Teoretiko-pravovyye problemy [State territory: Theoretical and legal problems]. Moscow, 50. Available at: https://www.dissercat.com/content/territoriya-gosudarstva-teoretiko-pravovye-problemy (in Russian).
Klimenko, B.M. (1982). Mirnoye resheniye mezhdunarodnykh sporov [Peaceful settlement of international disputes]. Moscow, 184 (in Russian).
Kononenko, V.P. & Tymchenko, L.D. (2014). Terytorialni superechky – sudovi ta sylovi formaty vyrishennia [Territorial disputes – judicial and force formats of resolution]. Ukrainian Revolution of Dignity, Russia, and International Law: a collective monograph. Kyiv, 310–327 (in Ukrainian).
O nezavisimosti Kryma: postanovleniye Verkhovnogo Soveta AR Krym ot 17.03.2014 № 1745-6/14 [On the independence of Crimea: the resolution of the Supreme Council of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea]. Available at: https://www.rada.crimea.ua/act/11748 (in Russian).
Deklaratsiya o suverenitete Donetskoy Narodnoy Respubliki ot 07.04.2014 [Declaration of the sovereignty of the Donetsk People's Republic]. Available at: http://medialeaks.ru/statements/deklaraciya-o-nezavisimosti-doneckoj-narodnoj-respubliki (in Russian).
Deklaratsiya o provozglashenii nezavisimosti i gosudarstvennom suverenitete Luganskoy Narodnoy Respubliki [Declaration on the proclamation of independence and state sovereignty of the Luhansk People's Republic]. How do they want to separate the Luhansk region? Intercepted scenario. Available at: http://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/articles/2014/05/6/7024570/ (in Russian).
Akt o provozglashenii gosudarstvennoy samostoyatelnosti Donetskoy Narodnoy Respubliki ot 07.04.2014 [Act on the proclamation of state independence of the Donetsk People's Republic]. Available at: http://medialeaks.ru/statements/deklaraciya-o-nezavisimosti-doneckoj-narodnoj-respubliki (in Russian).
Konstitutsiya Respubliki Krym ot 11.04.2014 [Constitution of the Republic of Crimea]. Available at: http://www.crimea.gov.ru/content/uploads/files/ Constituciya.pdf (in Russian).
Konstitutsiya Donetskoy Narodnoy Respubliki ot 14.05.2014 [Constitution of the Donetsk People's Republic]. Available at: https://dnrsovet.su/konstitutsiya/ (in Russian).
Konstitutsiya Luganskoy Narodnoy Respubliki ot 18.05.2014 [Constitution of the Luhansk People's Republic]. Available at: https://glava-lnr.info/dokumenty/konstituciya (in Russian).
Lukashuk, I.I. (2005). Mezhdunarodnoye pravo. Obshchaya chast [International law. General part: textbook]. Moscow: Volters Kluver, 432. Available at: http://www.cawater-info.net/bk/water_law/pdf/lukashuk_1.pdf (in Russian).
Narod [People]. Available at: http://uk.wikipedia.org/wiki/Народ (in Ukrainian).
Higgins, R. (1994). Problems and Process. International Law and How We Use It. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 274 (in English).
Butkevych, V.H. (2002). Poniattia, pryroda ta sfera dii mizhnarodnoho prava [The concept, nature, and scope of international law]. International law. Fundamentals of theory: textbook. Kyiv: Lybid, 608. Available at: https://www.studmed.ru/butkevich-vg-red-mzhnarodne-pravoosnovi-teoryi_4f0ee557b5a.html (in Ukrainian).
Tolstykh, V.L. (2009). Kurs mezhdunarodnogo prava: uchebnik [International law course: textbook]. Moscow: Volters Kluver, 1056 (in Russian).
Territorialnaya tselostnost Ukrainy: Rezolyutsiya Generalnoy Assamblei OON № 68/262 ot 27.03.2014 [Territorial integrity of Ukraine: UN General Assembly resolution]. Available at: http://www.un.org/ru/documents/ ods.asp?m=A/RES/68/262 (in Russian).
European Parliament resolution of 17 July 2014 on Ukraine (2014/2717(RSP)). Available at: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/ TA-8-2014-0009_EN.html (in English).
Korotkyi, T.R., Merezhko, O.O. & Pleshko, E.A. (2014). Proholoshennia «DNR» i «LNR» i pravo narodiv na samovyznachennia: iliuzornyi suverenitet chy suverenitet iliuzii [Proclamation of «DPR» and «LPR» and the right of peoples to self-determination: illusory sovereignty or sovereignty of illusions]. Ukrainian Revolution of Dignity, Russia, and International Law: a collective monograph. Kyiv, 685–717 (in Ukrainian).
Sayapin, S. Sovremennyye vyzovy mezhdunarodnomu pravu [Contemporary challenges to international law]. Available at: http://m.zakon.kz/4681800-sovremennye-vyzovy-mezhdunarodnomu.html (in Russian).
Downloads
Additional Files
Published
Issue
Section
License
Relationship between right holders and users shall be governed by the terms of the license Creative Commons Attribution – non-commercial – Distribution On Same Conditions 4.0 international (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0):https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/deed.uk
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
